Checking a beam: from load to IPE selection
Two sections may satisfy strength requirements yet differ on the actual governing criterion: deflection.
The classic trap is to calculate σ = M/W, observe moderate stress and declare the beam suitable. Yet deflection may be excessive; an unbraced open section may also be susceptible to lateral-torsional buckling. This method therefore starts with a precise static model, then compares two IPE sections with properties from a manufacturer's catalogue.
1. Data to gather before calculation
| Input | How to obtain it | Common error |
|---|---|---|
| Span and supports | Distance between support axes; identify pin/roller or actual fixed restraint. | Treating a welded joint as perfectly fixed without evidence. |
| Service loads | Suspended mass, equipment, distributed load, self-weight; specify combinations. | Omitting self-weight or fictitiously distributing a concentrated load. |
| I and W | Section catalogue, same axis and orientation. | Confusing cm⁴, mm⁴ and section modulus in cm³. |
| E and limits | Material at operating temperature; criteria from the project / applicable code. | Using a universal deflection limit; L/500 is an exercise assumption here. |
2. Solve the problem in the correct order
1 Establish reactions and maximum moment
For a point force F halfway between two simple supports, each support carries F/2 and maximum moment is FL/4. If the load is offset, distributed or supports differ, this result no longer applies. The load sketch is a calculation deliverable, not decoration.
2 Obtain I and W about the correct axis
For the strong axis, the ArcelorMittal catalogue gives IPE 160 : I = 869 cm⁴, W = 109 cm³ and IPE 200 : I = 1 940 cm⁴, W = 194 cm³. Retain the catalogue's y-y axes in the calculation report; physically rotating the beam may switch to a much smaller second moment of area.
See our IPE table extract with units and source.
3 Check elastic stress
With M in N·mm and W in mm³, M/W gives MPa directly. In this case, the comparison limit of 140 MPa is a fictitious exercise criterion : it is neither a Eurocode limit nor a calculated structural resistance.
4 Check deflection, then the checks not covered
This beam's central deflection is FL³/(48EI). It depends on the cube of the span : increasing span by 10 % already increases deflection by about 33 % if all else stays equal. L/500 (8 mm at 4 m) is selected for this exercise; a project may require another limit depending on use, finishes and vibrations.
3. Full example: why the lightest section fails
Teaching assumptions: F = 12 kN at midspan, L = 4 m, E = 210 GPa, comparison limit σ = 140 MPa, deflection limit L/500 = 8 mm. Idealized service load; self-weight is excluded from the deflection calculation below and must be added for a complete study.
| Section | σ (MPa) | δ (mm) | Mass over 4 m | Exercise conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IPE 160 | 110.09 | 8.77 | 63.2 kg | Stress OK, deflection > 8 mm |
| IPE 200 | 61.86 | 3.93 | 89.6 kg | Both criteria met |
Formulaxis calculations using ArcelorMittal properties; the finding applies only to this elastic bending case and the selected fictitious limits.
Reproduce the calculation and vary the section
Change section, load or span: both criteria and mass are recalculated. Geometric properties remain those of the ArcelorMittal catalogue, strong axis.
4. Practical advice: what this model misses
Do not confuse strong axis with “a sufficiently strong beam”
An IPE section loaded about its weak axis may deflect far more under the same load. Always record orientation and draw manufacturer axes in the calculation report; “I = 1 940 cm⁴” without an axis is ambiguous.
Lateral-torsional buckling may govern before yielding
If the compression flange is not laterally restrained, the section may buckle laterally and twist. Neither σ = M/W nor δ = FL³/(48EI) verifies this instability. Bracing, unrestrained length and applicable structural-code rules require separate study.
A “perfect” beam case may hide an incorrect static model
A distributed load is sometimes too quickly replaced by a point force, or a real support assumed perfectly fixed. Draw a free-body diagram, check ∑F = 0 and ∑M = 0, then document every assumption. Engineers' discussions of modeling errors confirm the value of this initial check; they do not replace a standard.
5. From the method to Formulaxis
In practice, follow the tools in order: geometric properties → maximum moment → bending stress → deflection → mass. Enter your values into the calculators below, keeping the stated units and assumptions.
Reusable reference: IPE 160 to 220: I, W and mass per metre. Continue with checking cylinder-rod buckling to understand how an instability other than bending may govern a slender component.
Sources and data status
Numerical values are retained in this document even if URLs change. The tables are reconstructed selections with source attribution, not full copies of brochures. Formulaxis calculations and teaching assumptions are identified separately.
- ArcelorMittal — Orange Book, IPE propertiesIPE I, W, mass and axes; geometry source.
- Technical discussion — defining load-diagram assumptionsPractical experience on reactions, support conditions and load paths.
Sources consulted / results cross-checked on 15 November 2026. Data sheets and catalogues may be revised: check the current edition for a real project.