Skip to content
Formulaxis
Threaded joints · Method + reproducible examples

Tightening torque: find the right data before calculating

A torque of 107 N·m does not mean the same thing on a dry bolt and a lubricated bolt. We start with manufacturer documents, learn how to determine the K factor and check what the figures actually allow us to conclude.

01 — Start with a real example

Reproduce a manufacturer's value

Click an example to update the values and table extracts. You do not need to know K to get started.

Values read from the documentation
Nord-Lock — M12 property class 8.8

NL12 washers, zinc-plated bolt, oil lubrication (WD-40 in the manual).

Published torque107 N·m
Published preload40 kN
ThreadM12 × 1.75
Property class8.8
Factor derived from published data
0.223 — equivalent K factor

K = 107 / (40 000 × 0.012) = 0.223

Using the published friction values and simplified geometry, our torque estimate is 110.8 N·m (difference +3.5 %). This is not a validation test.

Do not confuse these concepts. Deriving K from T and F is not manufacturer validation. Nor does a single K value allow a “guaranteed” preload range to be calculated.

I have a measured K range: estimate preload bounds

Only complete these fields if your K bounds come from measurements or applicable technical documentation. For learning, use the “illustrative assumption” button, clearly distinguished from manufacturer data.

Lowest friction
Highest friction
Assumption about tool + process
From the joint analysis, never a generic table
No range calculated: K bounds and torque variation are not published for the currently loaded example.
Step 1 / 5 — Locate the data

Start with the manufacturer's row, not an arbitrary K value

In the Nord-Lock table, first select property class 8.8, then the product NL12. Then read the column matching the lubrication condition. The manufacturer publishes torque and preload together; both relate to this configuration.

ProductAssembly conditionTorquePreloadµ threadµ under head
NL12 / M12Oil (WD-40)107 N·m40 kN0.150.19
NL12 / M12Dry97 N·m33 kN0.180.20
NL16 / M16Dry237 N·m62 kN0.180.20

Table coefficients: oil — μ thread 0.15, μ under head 0.19; dry — μ thread 0.18, μ under head 0.20.

Selected extract — Nord-Lock, “steel washers / bolt grade 8.8” tableOfficial original

Watch the percentages: the table specifies GF = 75 % of yield strength for oil, but 62 % for dry conditions. Comparing 107 N·m directly with 97 N·m to isolate the lubricant's influence would be incorrect: the target preload also changes.

For the Bossard example, the 2025 document describes an M12 × 40 bolt, property class 8.8, electroplated with zinc, with µ = 0.14 in the threads and under the head. The row gives 93 N·m and an upper preload of 41.9 kN. Bossard then uses a tightening factor αA of 1.8 and derives a lower preload of 23.3 kN.

Boltµ thread / under headFmax 8.8Maximum torque 8.8
M12 × 400.14 / 0.1441.9 kN93 N·m
Selected extract — Bossard 2025, pages 60 and 62Official PDF, table p. 62

Useful habit: always record the reference, row, column, coating, lubricant and document version. An isolated figure in a spreadsheet quickly becomes impossible to justify.

Step 2 / 5 — Understand the phenomenon

What the wrench controls and what the bolt experiences

During tightening, the bolt elongates slightly while the joined parts are compressed. We generally seek this preload, but the wrench controls only the applied torque. Thread friction and bearing-surface friction consume a substantial share of the torque.

Preload: tensionin the bolt Compressed partsbetween head and nut Frictionthread and bearing surfaces
Formulaxis schematic, not to scale. Actual forces depend on geometry, component stiffness and contact surfaces.

A numerical example published by Bolt Science splits 54.70 N·m into 30.58 N·m of bearing friction, 17.46 N·m of thread friction and only 6.66 N·m for generating tension. This is not a universal distribution, but it explains why a slight surface difference can significantly change the result.

Friction under head / nut: 56 %Thread: 32 %Tension generation: 12 %Specific Bolt Science example — 54.70 N·m
Formulaxis chart based on the numerical example from Bolt Science (Bill Eccles). It explains the mechanisms; it does not establish a percentage applicable to all bolts.
Step 3 / 5 — A difficult parameter

How can you obtain K without inventing a range?

The simplified formula T = K × F × d combines friction and geometry into one factor. K is not the coefficient of friction µ. For the lubricated M12 in the Nord-Lock table, we obtain an equivalent factor of 0.223 from 107 / (40 000 × 0.012). This reproduces a ratio between two published values; it does not measure uncertainty.

There are three possible routes, depending on the documents available:

  1. The manufacturer publishes T and F. Calculate equivalent K to reproduce the row. Do not infer Kmin or Kmax : scatter data are missing.
  2. It publishes µ in the thread and under the head. K can be estimated using bolt and bearing geometry. Explain the selected formula and geometry; any µ interval must be documented.
  3. You need to substantiate your own joint. Look for a torque–preload study applicable to the coating, lubricant, surfaces and process. Otherwise, plan representative measurements; do not replace missing data with fictitious precision.
Manufacturer's T + FEquivalent KA single pointNo scatter data µ + geometryEstimated KExplicit assumptionsRanges if documented Representative testsMeasured K valuesScope of applicationand scatter to establish
Three traceability routes. A value calculated from a table is not an independent measurement.

The reference NL12 specifies, among other dimensions, an inside diameter of 13 mm and an outside diameter of 19.5 mm. The Formulaxis geometric estimate uses these dimensions, the 1.75 mm pitch and the published µ values. The difference from 107 N·m must remain visible: the effective bearing-friction diameter is simplified and contact assumptions are limited.

Step 4 / 5 — Run a controlled experiment

Same torque, two contact conditions: what changes?

A comparison is more informative when you keep the same torque. The two Nord-Lock M12 rows have different target preloads, so the published torques cannot be compared directly with the difference attributed solely to friction. Instead, we use the two reconstructed equivalent K values and apply them at a common torque to illustrate sensitivity.

107 N·m
NL12 oil
40.0 kN
NL12 dry
36.4 kN

At 107 N·m, the model gives about 10 % more preload for the equivalent K of the oiled example.

The limitation of this experiment: these are not two tests performed at each slider value. A simplified relationship is extended around the manufacturer's two data points; the result is not a new tightening instruction. Changing the lubricant requires a requalified tightening procedure.

When entering data in a real tool, record the exact lubricant, application area (thread and/or bearing surface) and the surface actually rotated. “Oiled” alone is not precise enough to justify K.

Step 5 / 5 — Decide what can be concluded

A ± 3 % wrench does not give ± 3 % preload

A wrench's stated accuracy describes torque error under measurement conditions. Preload scatter also depends on friction, surfaces, sequence, geometry and possible embedment. Even accurately repeated torque therefore does not mean each bolt receives the same tension.

Calibrated tool± 3 %torque deviation FrictionVariable / unknown Kcoating, bearing surface, process Preload? kNbounds not established A “click” indicates a torque threshold, not a direct measurement of bolt tension.
Formulaxis conceptual diagram. Wrench accuracy alone does not cover torque–preload scatter.

Before issuing a tightening instruction or declaring preload sufficient, an engineer must also check the joint criteria: preload losses, separation under load, thread strength, bearing pressure, combined stresses, fatigue and inspection method. For critical cases, a study under the applicable procedure and rules replaces this simplified model.

Numerical application — illustrative study, not manufacturer data

Minimum assembly preload: which solution should be compared?

Assume a bolt M12 × 1.75 property class 10.9 and a fictitious requirement of 35 kN minimum assembly preload (editable below). The Optimas table gives a tabulated proof load of 70.0 kN for this size. For this exercise only, we limit the calculated upper bound to 85 % of this load, or 59.5 kN. This demonstration limit is not a combined tension–torsion check.

The torque is selected using the conditions most likely to cause excessive preload (minimum K and maximum actual applied torque). Minimum preload is then calculated using maximum K and minimum torque:

Tnom,max = Fupper · Kmin · d / (1 + e)   ;   Flower = Tnom,max · (1 − e) / (Kmax · d)
kN
This value is an exercise requirement. In a real engineering file, it comes from the loaded-joint calculation.
Learning scenarios: same bolt, same upper bound of 59.5 kN
AssumptionK rangeTool deviationSelected maximum torqueFlowerRequirement met?
1 · Poorly known friction0.18–0.30± 5 %122.4 N·m32.3 kNNo for 35 kN
2 · Same K, ± 3 % wrench0.18–0.30± 3 %124.8 N·m33.6 kNNo for 35 kN
3 · Better-characterized friction*0.19–0.25± 5 %129.2 N·m40.9 kNYes for 35 kN

* K = 0.19 to 0.25 is a range invented to compare two assumptions, NOT a Bossard or Nord-Lock value. Scenario 3 can only be used in a real procedure if measurements or applicable data actually justify these bounds.

Why not simply increase the torque? In scenario 1, targeting a lower bound of 35 kN would require about 132.6 N·m but would simultaneously raise the estimated upper bound to about 64.5 kN : above the 59.5 kN bound selected for this exercise. Increasing torque therefore does not resolve this contradiction.

Engineering decision: in this exercise, improving wrench accuracy alone is insufficient; controlling contact conditions could make the requirement achievable. Before any real conclusion, you must justify the K bounds and required preload and check, at minimum, combined tension–torsion, bearing surfaces, the loaded joint and preload losses.

Field experience · Forums and specialists

Four pitfalls actually encountered in workshops

Forums help identify recurring problems; they do not replace a standard or manufacturer instructions. These situations discussed by professionals show which technical checks matter.

“The data sheet gives a dry torque, but the bolt was oiled”

Mechanics and engineers report this situation. The torque–preload relationship changes with the contacting surfaces. Do not adjust torque by a universal percentage : find the procedure for the actual condition or characterize friction. For a Nord-Lock assembly, use the column for the actual condition and product selected. Discussion: r/MechanicalEngineering · Technical reference: Nord-Lock.

“I reapplied the wrench and it clicked: is my joint still tight?”

No, this does not measure residual tension. Breakaway torque depends in particular on static friction, which can change after assembly. Checking residual torque requires a specific procedure; if the actual requirement concerns bolt force, consider suitable preload or elongation measurement methods. Workshop question: r/engineering · Explanation: Bolt Science.

“If I tighten the head instead of the nut, is the torque identical?”

Not necessarily. Different surfaces, finishes or bearing dimensions can change friction at the rotating face. Record which component is rotated and use the same convention during development and production. Study: Bolt Science — nut or bolt head?.

“All bolts have the right torque, yet a flange loosens”

Also consider actual preload, surface embedment, tightening sequence, component behavior and temperature. A torque check does not cover embedment or loss of clamping force. For a flange, follow the prescribed tightening sequence and inspection procedure for that joint. Discussions: r/MechanicalEngineering · r/millwrights.

Use this in technical documentation

Information to record before tightening

At minimum, leave the following in an assembly sheet so a colleague can reproduce the calculation later:

Parts and geometry: diameter, pitch, property class, clamped length, tapped-hole or nut type, bearing geometry.
Surface condition: coating, exact lubricant, application points, washer used, rotating face.
Method: torque/angle/tension, sequence, tool, calibration status, effective operating range.
Justification: required minimum preload, acceptable limits, source of K or µ, established scatter, source and date.

Decision: knowing only bolt size and property class lets you calculate nominal proof load; it does not establish a reliable assembly torque for your joint.

Traceability

Verified sources and scope

The tables above include only the rows needed for the demonstration. Manufacturer names and values are attributed to their sources; diagrams, interpretations and sensitivity experiments are Formulaxis work.

  1. Nord-Lock, Torque Guidelines — property class 8.8, M12 and M16 rows, Oil / Dry columns; thread and under-head µ, GF and WD-40 note.
  2. Nord-Lock, NL12 data sheet and NL16 — washer dimensions used for the geometric estimate.
  3. Bossard, Preload and tightening torques, January 2025 — page 60, M12 × 40 example; page 62, reference table.
  4. Optimas, metric thread proof loads — values reproduced from EN ISO 898-1 to check the order of magnitude of proof load.
  5. Bolt Science, Bill Eccles, “What should be tightened — the nut or the bolt head?” — example of torque distribution and influence of the rotated face.
  6. Bolt Science, FAQ — limitations of retrospective torque inspection.
  7. Field experience: r/MechanicalEngineering ; r/engineering ; r/millwrights — used to identify common problems, not as normative references.

Another Formulaxis resource: M6 to M24 proof-load table, based on values published by Optimas.

Scope: Illustrative study of metric steel bolts using equivalent K and a simplified friction model; does not check combined tension–torsion stress, thread strength, fatigue, contact pressure, vibration or preload loss. Manufacturer examples are documented data points, not software certification or ready-to-use instructions.